Payments Health Score

What is your Payments Health Score?

You're running a business. Your payment system should run with it. The Payments Health Score is SilverEdge's diagnostic of how money moves into, out of, and through your business, scored on a 0 to 100 scale, across the five dimensions that decide whether payments feel predictable or feel like friction.

By SilverEdge, Loveland, Colorado. Takes about seven minutes. Your score and results by category on completion.

What the Payments Health Score is

The Payments Health Score is a proprietary diagnostic created and run by SilverEdge, a payments architecture firm in Loveland, Colorado.

The Payments Health Score measures how deliberately money moves in and out of your business, across five dimensions, on a 0 to 100 scale.

It examines how invoices turn into cash, how vendor payments are approved and controlled, whether the pieces connect to your ERP and someone owns the whole, what payments cost and whether cash timing can be forecast, and how company cards, receipts and coding are run. It turns that examination into one score on a 0 to 100 scale, with a result for each dimension.

SilverEdge uses the Payments Health Score as one diagnostic among its tools. It is not the entry point to every engagement. Where it is used, diagnosis comes before any design work and before any discussion of pricing. That order matters. Most payment problems are not vendor problems or rate problems. They are design problems, and you cannot design a system you have not diagnosed first.

The score is not a grade, a quote, or a sales estimate. It is a starting point: a clear, scored picture of where payment friction is most likely sitting in your business, and what is worth looking at first.

Most payments systems were accumulated, not designed

Most growing companies add payment tools one decision at a time. A processor when the first customer asks to pay by card. A payables tool when the check run gets too long. A card program when travel picks up. Each choice made sense on the day it was made.

Years later, money in, money out, cards and card acceptance are handled by different vendors and different people, and none of them is accountable for how the pieces fit together. Nothing is obviously broken. But cash arrives less predictably than it should, reconciliation takes longer every month, and nobody can draw the whole system on one page.

The Payments Health Score measures that gap: between a payments system that was designed and one that simply accumulated.

The five dimensions of the Payments Health Score

Every score is built from the same five dimensions. Together they cover the whole system, because a weakness in any one of them shows up as friction in the others.

DimensionWhat it covers
1. Money InHow invoices turn into cash, and how predictably
2. Money OutHow vendor payments are approved, routed and controlled
3. Architecture & OwnershipWhether the pieces connect to the ERP and someone owns the whole
4. Cost & PredictabilityWhat payments cost and whether cash timing can be forecast
5. Card & ExpenseHow company cards, receipts and coding are run

ScoreApp also reports a sixth count, "Line of sight," alongside the five dimensions. The five dimensions above are what the score itself is built from.

1. Money In: how invoices turn into cash, and how predictably

This dimension looks at the distance between doing the work and having the money: how invoices go out, what payment options a customer actually gets, how much follow-up a payment takes, and how cleanly payments post back to the enterprise resource planning (ERP) system. More on Money In.

  • Strong: Customers are offered an easy, obvious way to pay, not just a mailed check or a phone call. Payments post and reconcile without manual re-entry, and days sales outstanding stays close to your stated terms.
  • Worth a look: Invoices go out on time but payment depends on reminders, phone calls and checks, and every receipt becomes a small reconciliation project.

2. Money Out: how vendor payments are approved, routed and controlled

This dimension looks at who can pay whom, by which method, with what approval, and whether those controls would hold up on a bad day, not just a normal one. It covers payment mix across check, automated clearing house (ACH) and card, vendor onboarding, and who is able to change vendor bank details. More on Money Out.

  • Strong: Every payment has an owner, an approval path, and a deliberate method: check, ACH or card chosen on purpose, vendor by vendor.
  • Worth a look: Approvals live in inboxes, vendor bank details can be changed on a single request, and nobody has reviewed the payment mix in years.

3. Architecture & Ownership: whether the pieces connect to the ERP and someone owns the whole

This dimension looks at the system itself: every tool, gateway, processor and platform that touches money, how each one connects to your ERP, and whether anyone is accountable for the whole. It is the dimension most diagnostics skip, and usually the one underneath the other four.

  • Strong: Someone can draw the whole system on one page, and a named person owns it end to end.
  • Worth a look: Each tool was bought to solve one problem, integrations are partial or manual, and when something drifts, it is nobody's job to notice.

The score is designed around the ERP you already run, including Epicor BisTrack, Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central, NetSuite, and QuickBooks Online at multi-entity scale. Nothing in this diagnostic assumes you should replace it.

4. Cost & Predictability: what payments cost and whether cash timing can be forecast

This dimension is not about chasing a lower rate. It looks at whether the cost of accepting and sending payments is the cost you intended: whether fee structures are stable and understood, whether fees are handled and disclosed correctly, and whether cost has quietly drifted as volumes, payment mix and entities have changed.

  • Strong: You can explain what you pay, why you pay it, and when it last changed, and the answer still matches the original design.
  • Worth a look: Fees are a line nobody opens, structures have drifted since they were set, and cost surprises arrive after the fact instead of before it.

SilverEdge discusses specific pricing only after the architecture conversation, never before it. A cost structure can only be judged once you can see the system it is paying for. Where card acceptance is part of the picture, see how SilverEdge approaches card acceptance.

5. Card & Expense: how company cards, receipts and coding are run

This dimension looks at how company cards, receipts and coding are run: how cards are issued, what limits and policies sit on them, how receipts are captured, and how transactions are coded to jobs, departments or entities. More on Card & Expense.

  • Strong: Policies are defined before the card is swiped, spend is visible in real time, and coding happens as a by-product, not as a month-end cleanup.
  • Worth a look: Cards are shared, receipts are chased, and expense data reaches the ERP late, incomplete, or re-keyed by hand.

How it works

  1. Take the score. About seven minutes. Answer questions about how money moves through your business today: how customers pay you, how you pay vendors, which systems you run, and how spend is controlled. There are no documents to gather and no statements to upload.
  2. See your score. You receive one score on a 0 to 100 scale, a result for each of the five dimensions, and the areas worth looking at first, in order.
  3. Review what it means with SilverEdge. If you want to go further, we walk through the results together and talk about how your payments system should be designed. That conversation is about architecture. Pricing is discussed after it, never before it.

What your score means

Most mid-market companies land in the middle tiers, not because anyone failed, but because growth adds tools faster than anyone redesigns the system around them.

Your score falls in one of four tiers. Read the tier as a description of how the system was built, not as a judgment of the people running it.

ScoreTierWhat it usually means
80 to 100DesignedMoney in, money out, systems, costs and spend were designed as one system, and someone is keeping them that way as the business changes.
60 to 79FunctionalThe system works day to day, but parts have drifted since they were set up. One or two dimensions are carrying friction the others create.
40 to 59StrainedThe tools each work; the system does not. Expect manual reconciliation, unpredictable timing, and no single owner for how money moves.
0 to 39UndesignedPayment friction is likely costing time and control every week. Start with the lowest-scoring dimension. The score shows you which one it is.

Whatever the tier, the most useful number on the page is not the total. It is the lowest dimension. That is where designed work starts.

Who the Payments Health Score is for

The score was built for the person who owns money movement in a mid-market business, typically the chief financial officer, controller, or chief executive, at a company that has outgrown the payments setup it started with.

  • Business-to-business companies in construction, building supply and distribution, manufacturing, multi-entity holding companies, and professional services with heavy invoicing.
  • Companies running an ERP: Epicor BisTrack, Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central, NetSuite, or QuickBooks Online across multiple entities.
  • Businesses where several payment methods, several vendors, and more than one person touch money in or money out. That is typically a company with roughly $5 million to $200 million in revenue.

If your payments still run through one tool and one person, you probably do not need a diagnostic yet. If you read the list above and recognized your own month-end, you do.

Companies SilverEdge has worked with

SilverEdge designs payments for mid-market companies that have outgrown an accumulated setup. Clients approved to be named here include Backbone Fiber and ECC, alongside Trice Jewelers, AAA Roofing and Chelo's.

Their names appear here because each company approved being named, including the use of its logo and its story. SilverEdge does not publish a client's name, logo or results without that approval.

Payments Health Score or Statement Analyzer? They are not the same thing

SilverEdge offers two different diagnostics, and they answer different questions. This page is about the first one.

Payments Health ScoreStatement Analyzer
The question it answersHow well is our whole payments system designed?What does this one processing statement say about our card acceptance costs and setup?
What it looks atThe whole system: Money In, Money Out, Architecture & Ownership, Cost & Predictability, and Card & ExpenseA single merchant processing statement, for card acceptance only
How it worksA structured assessment you complete in about seven minutes, with no documents to gatherYou submit a current processing statement for review
What you getA score on a 0 to 100 scale, results across five dimensions, and the areas worth looking at firstA review of that statement and what it shows
Who it is forCFOs, controllers and CEOs considering the design of their whole payments systemBusinesses whose immediate question is about accepting card payments
The conversation afterPayments architecture: how money should move through the businessCard acceptance, one part of the wider system

If your only question today is about a processing statement, the Statement Analyzer is the right tool, and this score is not a substitute for it. If your question is bigger, why money moves the way it does and whether it should, start with the Payments Health Score.

What happens after your score

A score on its own changes nothing. What it does is tell both of us where to look first, so the next conversation is specific instead of general.

1. Diagnosis. We start with your lowest-scoring dimensions and learn how money actually moves through your business today, across every vendor and every person who touches it.

2. Design. We design the system around the ERP you already run: money in, money out, spend and card acceptance as one system, with one accountable owner.

3. Deployment. Rollout happens in phases, so daily operations keep running while each part goes live.

4. Accountability. We stay involved after go-live, reviewing performance, exceptions and drift, and re-scoring your Payments Health Score on a regular schedule so the system stays designed as the business changes.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Payments Health Score?

The Payments Health Score measures how deliberately money moves in and out of your business, across five dimensions, on a 0 to 100 scale. The five dimensions are Money In, Money Out, Architecture & Ownership, Cost & Predictability, and Card & Expense. It is SilverEdge's proprietary diagnostic of how money moves through a business.

Who created the Payments Health Score?

SilverEdge, a payments architecture firm based in Loveland, Colorado. SilverEdge created the Payments Health Score as one of its diagnostics; it is not the entry point to every engagement. The work is led by Ken Salazar, Chief Payments Architect.

How long does it take?

About seven minutes. You answer questions about how money moves through your business today. There are no documents to gather and no statements to upload.

What do I get when I finish?

A score on a 0 to 100 scale, a result for each of the five dimensions, and the areas worth looking at first, in order. ScoreApp also reports a sixth "Line of sight" count alongside the five dimensions.

Is the Payments Health Score the same as the Statement Analyzer?

No. They are separate SilverEdge offers. The Payments Health Score diagnoses your whole payments system across five dimensions. The Statement Analyzer reviews one merchant processing statement, for card acceptance only.

Will the score tell me what I could save or what rate I should pay?

No, and that is deliberate. The score diagnoses the design of your system. SilverEdge discusses pricing only after the architecture conversation, because a cost can only be judged once you can see the system it is paying for.

Do we need to replace our ERP or accounting system to use the results?

No. The diagnostic is designed around the ERP you already run, including Epicor BisTrack, Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central, NetSuite, and QuickBooks Online at multi-entity scale.

What happens after I get my score?

Nothing automatic. If you want to go further, SilverEdge will walk through the results with you and talk about how your payments system should be designed, starting with your lowest-scoring dimension.

You've built the business. Now see how money moves through it.

Seven minutes. One score on a 0 to 100 scale. A clear view of where payment friction is sitting, and what is worth looking at first.

SilverEdge is a payments architecture firm in Loveland, Colorado. It designs how money moves in and out of mid-market businesses across accounts receivable, accounts payable, expense management, and merchant services, built around the client's existing ERP, and stays accountable after go-live. Not affiliated with SilverEdge Government Solutions.